West Harrison Man Sentenced To Home Incarceration In Animal Cruelty Case

All three felony convictions were entered as misdemeanors on Tuesday.

Joseph Stubbers III. File photo.

(Lawrenceburg, Ind.) - Joseph Stubbers III will not face any additional jail time in an animal cruelty case. 

Stubbers was sentenced on Tuesday to 730 days with 545 days suspended to probation. He will serve 185 days on in home incarceration as all three felony convictions for Torturing or Mutilating an Animal were entered as misdemeanors. 

The Judge also ordered that Stubbers pay restitution of $4,145 to P.A.W.S. In addition, Stubbers may not harbor, train, or own any companion pets for the period of his probation. 

In 2019, Stubbers was arrested after he struck then five-year old English Mastiff, Cooper, in the head with a hammer. He also shot Cooper twice, resulting in Cooper losing an eye. 

Stubbers took the stand at a sentencing hearing last week to apologize for his actions, stating the actions "were not in his general character or nature and that it will never happen again." 

The State requested the Court keep the felony convictions in place and sentence Stubbers to jail time, as did the Prosecutor's Office. 

"With deference and respect to the Court, my office argued at the Sentencing Hearing, that these felony convictions remain as felonies, and we also asked for jail time," said Dearborn County Prosecutor Lynn Deddens. 

Stubbers could still have his medical license suspended or revoked. That decision will be up to the Ohio Medical Board.  

RELATED STORIES

Sentencing Pushed To Next Week In Animal Cruelty Case

Jury Convicts Man Accused Of Animal Cruelty

Animal Cruelty Charge After Dog Hit With Hammer, Shot

More from Local News

Events

Jac-Cen-Del School Board Ratifies New Two-Year Teacher Contract

The new contract will take effect immediately.

Heart Health Group Receives DCF Proactive Grant

The grant is part of the Foundation’s annual program.

OHSAA Member Schools Pass NIL Referendum Proposal

Schools vote in favor of emergency referendum; Ohio becomes 45th state to allow NIL at the high school level.

Local Sports Report - November 21-22, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Little Big Town Hell Yeah 22:19
Johnny Paycheck Take This Job And Shove It 22:16
Patty Loveless Hurt Me Bad [in a Real Good Way] 22:12
Eric Church Hell On The Heart 22:09