Big Mac Bribe Doesn't Work For Accused Card Game Cheater

Maybe he should have offered to super size the bribe?

Justin Athey. Photo by Dearborn County Sheriff's Department.

(Lawrenceburg, Ind.) - A man’s fast food bribe attempt did not prevent him from being arrested by Indiana Gaming Commission agents.

Justin Athey, 34, was allegedly caught cheating at a table game at Hollywood Casino Lawrenceburg on July 24. A dealer caught him attempting to “past post” bets.

When he was caught by agents, Athey allegedly claimed he didn’t mean to place extra chips in the betting area and he wouldn’t try to cheat the casino.

He also attempted to bribe the agents not to charge him.

“I’ll get you as many free Big Macs that you want,” he said, according to a probable cause affidavit filed in court.

Athey was charged with Cheating at a Gambling Game (level 6 felony) on August 7. He was booked into jail in Dearborn County on September 5.

More from Local News


Events

Southeast Indiana Travel Advisories

Winter Storm Warning runs until Monday at noon.

Applications Available for OCCF 2026 Scholarships

Application deadlines are February 27.

SEI Football Stars Earn Academic All-State Honors

Congratulations to all the honorees!

Local Sports Report - January 22, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Miranda Lambert Gunpowder And Lead 14:24
Kelsea Ballerini Homecoming Queen? 14:21
Randy Travis Too Gone Too Long 14:19
Lonestar I'm Already There 14:13