Sherman House Restaurant & Inn To Open Under New Ownership

By Travis Thayer (Batesville, Ind.) – A historic local restaurant will be re-opening its doors under new ownership. Peyton Hughes and Georg Heringer, owners of HPH Hospitality, and operators of the Indy Lodge in Indianapolis, announced Tuesday that they have purchased the historic Sherman House Restaurant & Inn located in downtown Batesville. The Old World German and American cuisine restaurant previously closed its doors in January 2015 for cleaning and maintenance. After two weeks of cleaning and maintenance, the restaurant’s previous owner Doug Bessler made the difficult decision to not re-open the establishment. Bessler did however continue to work with the City of Batesville and local real estate agents in effort to find a new owner to re-open the restaurant that had been serving Batesville residents and traveler since 1865. That came to fruition on Tuesday. The new owners intend to apply a new coat of authentic German paint to the Sherman House. They also plan to renovate the entire building to retain its historic integrity. A grand re-opening date has not been announced at this time. The Sherman House first opened in 1865 as The Brinkman House. The establishment, which also includes 23 guest rooms, won the Hoosier Hospitality Award in 2008. RELATED STORIES: Report: Investors Seeking Incentives To Reopen Sherman House Sherman House Restaurant Won’t Reopen

More from Local News

Events

MMH Announces Long-Term Partnership with Revology

The partnership aims to support future growth and strengthen team member network.

NWS: Windy Conditions, Snow, Bitter Cold on the Way

Accumulating snow is expected on Thursday and Saturday.

Ribbon Cutting Held at New JCD Auxiliary Gym

The first game in the new gym was played last Saturday.

Local Sports Report - December 9, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Gabby Barrett - Dance Like No Ones Watching

Johnathan Lee X - That's How Christmas Used To Be 22:46
Miranda Lambert Vice 22:42
Garth Brooks Friends In Low Places 22:38
Chris Young I Didn't Come Here To Leave 22:34