Prosecutors Seek Life For Aurora Murder Suspect

Charles Robert Stephenson

file photo

 

Leigh Jennings

file photo

(Aurora, Ind.) – Dearborn County prosecutors will seek life in prison without parole for a man accused of murdering an Aurora woman.

 

Charles Robert Stephenson is accused of using a skillet and a pepper grinder to beat Leigh Jennings to death. The 67-year-old was found dead in her apartment on Aspen Ridge Road on April 5, 2012, investigators believe about a week after she died.

 

Prosecutors recently filed in Dearborn Circuit Court a notice of intent to seek life in prison without parole for Stephenson, 58, of Walton, Kentucky.

 

Dearborn-Ohio County Prosecutor Aaron Negangard said during a press conference announcing charges against Stephenson last May that the death penalty was a possibility in Jennings’ murder. If not life, he faces up to 115 years in prison if convicted on charges of Murder and Robbery.

 

Stephenson’s case is scheduled to go to jury trial on Monday, May 6. He has been ordered held in jail in Dearborn County pending trial.

 

Investigators allege that Stephenson needed to pay a court-ordered debt to a family member in order to avoid going to jail. He had previously borrowed $5,000 from Jennings. Following the murder, which detectives think may have occurred on March 29, Stephenson allegedly stole money from a safe in Jennings’ bedroom to pay the debt.

 

LINKS:

 

Stephenson Held Without Bond; Pleads Not Guilty

 

 

Murder Suspect Could Arrive In Indiana Wed.

 

Murder Suspect Charged; Used Pepper Grinder, Skillet

 

Judge Denies Stephenson Lower Bond

 

Ky. Prosecutors Link Stephenson To Aurora Murder

 

Person of Interest Indicted In Boone Co.

 

“Person of Interest” Arrested For Drugs

 

Police: Aurora Murder Victim Was Beaten To Death

 

Announcement Friday In Aurora Murder Case

 

Friend: Murder Victim Was Nurturing, Animal Lover

 

Friend Of Murder Victim Remains Hospitalized

 

Aurora, Florence Murders May Be Connected

 

Aurora Murder Investigation Continues

 

Death Investigation Underway In Aurora

 

 

 

 

More from Local News

Events

Local Schools Recognized for High Literacy Rates

Over 400 schools achieved a 95 percent or higher passage rate on the 2025 IREAD.

Indiana State Parks Offers Free Annual Entrance Passes for Foster Families

To get a pass, families need to fill out a short form.

Two Arrested on Drug Charges After Traffic Stop

The arrests occurred on Webers Lane in Franklin County.

Local Sports Report - April 23, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

EC's Perkins Sets School Record in 200 Meter Dash

The IU commit was on fire on Wednesday night.

Switz. Co. 7th Grader Sets School Record in Shot Put

The record was set at Wednesday night's quad meet in Vevay.

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Tracy Byrd - Holdin' Heaven

Easton Corbin Roll with It 13:56
Patty Loveless Blame It on Your Heart 13:49
Randy Travis Honky-Tonk Moon 13:46
Reba McEntire Turn On The Radio 13:40