Driver Sentenced For Resisting Law Enforcement Crash That Killed Two

The crash happened in the Madison area on January 9, 2020.

Blake Coombs. Photo by Indiana Department of Corrections. 

(Madison, Ind.) - Sentencing has been handed down for a man who caused a fatal crash while fleeing police.

It was January 9, 2020 when Madison Police attempted to conduct a traffic stop on a passenger vehicle, driven by then 18-year-old Blake Coombs.

The pursuit started on State Road 7 and continued to State Road 250, State Road 3, and then State Road 256 before the vehicle left the roadway and struck two utility polies near Thompson Road.

As result of the crash, Tyler Cooley, 18, of Hanover, and Brooklyn James, 19, of Madison, sustained fatal injuries.

According to the initial investigation, blood tests showed the Coombs had controlled substances and marijuana in his system at the time of the crash.

Coombs pleaded guilty to two counts of Resisting Law Enforcement Resulting in Death (Level 3 Felony) on April 20 in Jefferson County Court. 

During the hearing, families of the victims appeared to provide impact statements. Sandy Cooley, the grandmother of Tyler Cooney provided a written statement to be read in court:

“No amount of time you serve, Blake, will fix what you have done or bring back your victims. We just wish you hadn’t been so selfish or cowardly and faced the consequences of your actions. All you had to do was stop.”

Coombs was convicted on the lead charges, one for each victim. He was sentenced to 16 years behind bars with one year suspended to probation.

“This is a tragic and unfortunate reminder to obey traffic stops and pull over safely, even if you fear the consequences. I want to thank the families of the victims for their participation in the court process and for providing impact statements to the court. I am continuing to keep the family of these young victims in my prayers,” said Prosecutor David Sutter at the conclusion of the hearing.

RELATED STORIES

Man Arrested For Causing Fatal Crash While Fleeing Police

More from Local News

Events

YES Home Announces Historic Expansion Funded by Community Partners

The expansion will double the ability to care for youth and add 10 jobs to the local economy

Raw Sewage Discharge Affecting Area Rivers Has Been Resolved

The issue arose following severe storms and flooding last month.

FEMA Approves $2.1M to Hoosiers within First Week of Major Disaster Declaration

The deadline to apply for FEMA’s individual assistance is Oct. 25, 2026.

Switzerland County Golf Star Sets School Record

Alexis Mangold put together an incredible nine-hole round on Tuesday night.

Local Sports Report - September 1, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com 

Milan's Langferman Named MIFC Offensive Player of the Week

Langferman had a big game in a narrow loss to Batesville

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Kenny Chesney - Kenny Chesney - When The Sun Goes Down - Eagle Only

Fox News Fox News National Newscast 1:00
Lady A American Honey 0:56
Jelly Roll Heart of Stone 0:51
Lonestar No News 0:49