Deceased Male Leads to Arrest of Two North Vernon Women

No foul play is suspected in the death.

Wanda Arnold and Tina Pelsor. Photos by the Jennings County Sheriff's Office.

(Jennings County, Ind.) - The Jennings County Sheriffs Office responded to a 911 call on March 11 stating that a male had passed away. 

The caller told dispatchers that she had last spoke to the male approximately 20 minutes prior to finding him deceased. Upon arriving at the scene, deputies immediately recognized that the male had been deceased longer than what the caller had stated. 

At that time, deputies made contact with the caller, Tina Pelsor, who allegedly admitted that she had not given them an accurate timeline. 

In the process of further questioning, the Pelsor allegedly admitted to methamphetamine use and that there was methamphetamine and paraphernalia in the residence.

After receiving consent to search the resident, deputies located a female hiding in a closet. The female, Wanda Arnold, was detained and it was later learned that she had an active felony warrant through Jennings County. Deputies say both Pelsor and Arnold appeared to be intoxicated during interviews. 

Cause of death is still being determined by Jennings County Coroner's Office, however no foul play is suspected. Once the search of the bedrooms was completed, Pelsor and Arnold were taken to Jennings County Jail on the following preliminary charges:

Tina Pelsor

  • Possession of Paraphernalia- C Misdemeanor
  • Failure to Report a Dead Body- A Misdemeanor
  • Obstruction of Justice- Level 6 Felony
  • Assisting a Criminal- Level 6 Felony
  • Possession of Methamphetamine- Level 6 Felony

Wanda Arnold 

  • Possession of Paraphernalia- C Misdemeanor
  • Failure to Report a Dead Body- A Misdemeanor Warrant for Probation Violation for Possession of Methamphetamine- Level 6 Felony
  • Obstruction of Justice- Level 6 Felony
  • Possession of Methamphetamine- Level 6 Felony

More from Local News

Events

Volunteers Needed for Ohio River Sweep in Rising Sun

The litter clean-up event happens October 11.

Street Closures Announced for Lawrenceburg Fall Music Fest

The event runs Sept. 19-20 in Civic Park.

Life Center's Annula Hope 5K Set for October 18

The event supports neighbors facing addiction recovery, job loss, and other challenges

LHS Athletics, Tiger Basketball Seeking Sponsors for Annual Ray Furney Classic

The Ray Furney Classic will be played Jan. 2-3 at LHS and GMS.

Local Sports Report - September 15, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Blake Shelton - Guy with a Girl

Brooks & Dunn My Next Broken Heart 21:07
Jordan Foster They All Do 21:04
Fox News Fox News National Newscast 21:02
Mitchell Tenpenny We Got History 20:58