AG Hill: Federal Court Ruling Upholding Multiple Abortion Laws A Win For Indiana

Tuesday, October 13, 2020 at 9:13 AM

By Office of Attorney General Curtis Hill, news release

U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana upheld many statutes and regulations last week.

(Indianapolis, Ind.) - Attorney General Curtis Hill today applauded a federal court ruling that upheld against a due process challenge many critical abortion laws enacted by the Indiana General Assembly.

Last week, in response to a lawsuit filed by abortion provider Whole Woman’s Health challenging Indiana’s most significant abortion regulations, a judge for the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana upheld many statutes and regulations under the Due Process Clause. The laws the judge upheld include those:

  • requiring abortion clinics to be licensed;
  • requiring abortion providers to report abortions;
  • requiring abortion providers to have admitting privileges at nearby hospitals (or to have a back-up physician who does);
  • requiring women seeking abortion to have an ultrasound;
  • requiring abortion providers to make some mandatory disclosures to women as part of the abortion informed-consent process, and;
  • requiring women seeking abortion to wait 18 hours after an informed-consent consultation before having the abortion.

The judge also upheld under the Due Process Clause restrictions on the dosage and administration of the abortion drug mifepristone, as well as specifications for abortion clinic facilities. And finally, the judge affirmed under the Due Process Clause Indiana’s law requiring parental consent or a judicial bypass order before a minor can have an abortion.

“This ruling represents an important victory in Indiana’s efforts to defend life and promote the health of women seeking abortions,” Attorney General Hill said. “Our legislature has enacted common-sense abortion regulations that courts have long deemed constitutional, and this ruling affirms its prerogative to do so as a matter of constitutional due-process rights.”

A bench trial regarding the plaintiffs’ surviving due process and equal protection claims begins March 15, 2021. In addition to equal protection claims against the above-mentioned statutes, the plaintiffs are challenging Indiana laws that require, among other things:

  • that abortions be conducted by physicians;
  • that second-trimester abortions be conducted in hospitals or ambulatory surgical centers;
  • that women seeking abortions have an in-person examination and in-person informed-consent counseling before undergoing the abortion;
  • that women seeking abortions be told that human physical life begins when a human ovum is fertilized by a human sperm, that a fetus can feel pain from abortion, and that abortion entails both physical and mental health risks for the mother.

“We will continue to defend Indiana’s common-sense abortion laws from the meritless, self-interested attacks of abortion providers,” Attorney General Hill said.

The order is attached.

More from Local News


Events

Students Explore Vocational Trades at Career Pathways Camps at SCC

Students were exposed to trades such as welding, automotive technician, cosmetology, and veterinary technician.

Cincinnati Man Indicted on Charges Stemming from Fatal Accident on I-75 in NKY

A recorded jail call helped investigators make the arrest.

Cincinnati Burger Week Returns for 10th Anniversary

Enjoy $7 burgers at participating locations over a 10-day span of July.

East Central to Host 20+ Teams at Trojan Shootout

It has been a great summer for EC's girls teams: Varsity team going (7-3), JV (7-2), incoming 8th graders (5-1 in a JV league).

Goldsberry Hired as South Ripley Girls Varsity Basketball Head Coach

The Lady Raiders have won seven championships in the past five years.

First of Six SIRC Races Takes in Rushville

The Southeastern Indiana Racing Circuit returns June 29.

On Air

Alison Wiegand playing
Jimmy Wayne - I Love You This Much

Alabama Let's All Go Down To The River - PEC ONLY 7:54
Thompson Square If I Didn't Have You 7:48
Chris Tomlin Amazing Grace -PEC ONLY 7:44
Tom T. Hall Me and Jesus 7:41