US Marshals Arrest Suspects Wanted In Shooting Death At Greendale Hotel

The arrests were made Tuesday in Florence, Kentucky.

Demontre Conley and Talisha Tompkins. Photo provided. 

(Greendale, Ind.) - The two suspects wanted from a shooting death at a Greendale hotel have been taken into custody.

Demontre Conley, 19 and Talisha Tompkins, 21, both of Cincinnati, were arrested Tuesday by U.S. Marshals in Florence, Kentucky.

Conley and Tompkins were wanted for their involvement in the shooting death of David Bush-Reynolds. The 20-year-old from Cincinnati suffered a single gunshot wound to the head during an incident at the Riverside Inn in Greendale on September 26.

During the investigation, Greendale Police learned that a person had been shot in a room registered to Tompkins.

When police responded to the room, they found Bush-Reynolds deceased.

A witness to the shooting stated that he, Conley, Tompkins and Bush-Reynolds were partying and had video of them smoking marijuana and handling firearms prior to the gunshot that killed Bush-Reynolds.

After the shot went off, they fled. Conley told the witness that the shooting was an accident and that he did not know the gun was loaded.

Conley is charged with Reckless Homicide and Obstruction of Justice, while Tompkins is charged with Assisting a Criminal and Obstruction of Justice.

Both will have their initial hearing in Dearborn Superior Court I following extradition from Kentucky.

RELATED STORIES:

Two Suspects Wanted In Shooting Death At Greendale Hotel

More from Local News


Events

Greendale Main Street Acquires Historic Jones Building for Revitalization

The property is positioned to become a central hub for local commerce, community events, and everyday connection.

Groundbreaking Held at Future BWF Envirotec Facility in Greendale

BWF Envirotec is aleading global provider of all-in-one solutions for industrial filtration.

Happy Hooves Member Shares Experience at Mayberry West Farms

Mayberry West Farms recently hosted the Happy Hooves 4-H Livestock Club for an educational experience.

Guilford Native Drafted by LA Rams

Congratulations Max Klare!

Local Sports Report - April 24-25, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Local Sports Report - April 23, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Ty Herndon - What Mattered Most

Cole Swindell Chillin' It 22:23
Janie Fricke I'll Need Someone To Hold Me When I Cry 22:20
Cody Johnson Overdue 22:17
Mary Chapin Carpenter Passionate Kisses 22:13