Killer's DNA Found At Stephenson Murder Scene

Bill and Peggy Stephenson

file photo

(Florence, Ky.) – Boone County Sheriff’s Office investigators say there is a major break in the case of the double murder of Florence residents Bill and Peggy Stephenson.

 

The Stephensons, 74, were discovered murdered in their condominium on Ridge Edge Court on Memorial Day weekend of 2011. In the 15 months since, detectives have interviewed more than 200 people in 14 states. But, no arrests have been made as the murders remain unsolved.

 

Detectives announced Thursday that the Kentucky State Police Crime Lab in Frankfort recently discovered an unidentified DNA profile. The DNA was found in multiple locations at the murder scene.

 

The DNA has been entered into the FBI’s Combined DNA Index System, but has not produced a match.

 

Investigators also revealed that the murder suspect spent a significant amount of time in the Stephensons’ home after the murders. They’ve also been able to determine the time of the couple’s deaths.

 

A family member discovered their bodies after Bill did not show up for the Sunday service at the Truckers Chapel at the TA Truck Stop in Florence. The husband and wife also failed to show up at Union Baptist Church, as they did most every Sunday.

 

The Stephenson’s three adult children also announced that they have increase a reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction. The $5,000 reward first announced in January, has been upped to $100,000.

 

The Boone County Sheriff’s Office urges anyone with tips to call a special hotline, (859) 334-8496. There is also a webpage on the Boone County Sheriff's Office website dedicated to the investigation.

 

Detectives say they will continue their “aggressive” search for the killer.

 

LINKS:

 

 

Report: New Info On Stephenson Murders Coming

 

Murder Suspect Charged; Used Pepper Grinder, Skillet

 

Judge Denies Stephenson Lower Bond

 

Ky. Prosecutors Link Stephenson To Aurora Murder

 

Person of Interest Indicted In Boone Co.

 

“Person of Interest” Arrested For Drugs

 

Police: Aurora Murder Victim Was Beaten To Death

 

Announcement Friday In Aurora Murder Case

 

Friend: Murder Victim Was Nurturing, Animal Lover

 

Friend Of Murder Victim Remains Hospitalized

 

Aurora, Florence Murders May Be Connected

 

Aurora Murder Investigation Continues

 

Death Investigation Underway In Aurora

 

Children Of Murdered Couple Offering Reward

More from Local News

Events

Oxbow Nature Conservancy Added to Indiana Birding Trail

The Indiana Birding Trail is a curated collection of premier birding locations designed to connect people with birds.

Highway Plan Delivers 6-Year Outlook of Investments for Safe and Promising Future

Includes investments in major bi-state projects and safer, more efficient roads and bridges across the commonwealth.

Secretary of State Reminds Candidates of January 21 Campaign Finance Reporting Deadline

Indiana law requires candidates and campaign committees to periodically disclose contribution and expense details.

All-Sportsmanship Teams Announced for Fall Sports

Many area high schools earned First Team All-Sportsmanship.

Local Sports Report - January 15, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Local Sports Report - January 14, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Eagle Country 99.3 playing
Brad Paisley - American Saturday Night

Dolly Parton Star Spangled Banner 12:04
Fox News Fox News National Newscast 12:01
Tyler Hubbard 5 Foot 9 11:58
Rodney Atkins If You're Going Thru Hell 11:55