Double Shooting Suspect Taken Into Custody In Greendale

Greendale Police assisted with the arrest on Tuesday morning.

Photo provided by the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office. 

(Whitewater Township, Oh.) – The man wanted for his alleged role in a double shooting has been taken into custody.

Brian James was arrested on Tuesday around 8:30 a.m. at a motel in Greendale, according to Hamilton County Sheriff Jim Neil.

James was taken into custody by the Hamilton County Sheriff’s Office Fugitive Apprehension Unit with the assistance of Greendale Police.

The 23-year-old is a suspect in a double shooting that took place on Shore Lane in Whitewater Township on October 16.

During the incident, John Polly, 59, and Chris Black, 36, were shot multiple times. As result, both were transported to UC Medical Center with Black being listed in critical condition.

James is facing two counts of Felonious Assault (2nd degree Felony) and one count of Firing a Weapon into a Habitation (2nd degree Felony).

He is currently held in Dearborn County Jail awaiting extradition to Hamilton County.

RELATED STORIES

Suspect Identified In Whitewater Township Double Shooting

Double Shooting Under Investigation In Whitewater Township

More from Local News


Events

Frost Advisory, Freeze Watch Issued for Tri-State Area

Lows are expected to be near or below freezing the next two nights.

Share Your Thoughts with Five Minute Southeast Indiana Arts & Culture Plan Survey

The survey will shape the Arts and Culture Plan in six SEI counties.

Trick-or-Treat Times in Eagle Country

Halloween falls on Friday, October 31.

Local Players Highlight IHSVCA Academic All-State Team

Twenty-nine local players earned the honor.

Local Sports Report - October 20, 2025

East Central's girls soccer team competed at the regional round.

Curtis Eckstein Wins Half Marathon in Columbus

The former OA star can still run.

On Air

Ty Herndon What Mattered Most 18:05
Kip Moore More Girls Like You 18:03
Fox News Fox News National Newscast 18:01
Morgan Wallen Lies, Lies, Lies 17:58