Convicted Murderer Andrew Conley Returns To Rising Sun For Court Hearing

In 2009, Andrew Conley shook the small town to its core when he murdered his 10-year-old brother.

Andrew Conley. Photo by Dearborn County Sheriff's Department.

(Rising Sun, Ind.) – For the first time since his 2010 conviction, murderer Andrew Conley will be back in a southeastern Indiana courtroom Tuesday.

Now 26-years-old, Conley was 17 when he murdered his 10-year-old little brother, Conner Conley, in their Rising Sun home in 2009. Andrew strangled his sibling, then dumped his body near the city park.

Conley was sentenced to life in prison without parole in Ohio County Circuit Court in 2010.

Conley and his attorney first filed a petition for post-conviction relief in 2013. More than five years later, the request will finally get a court hearing.

On Monday, Conley was transported back to southeastern Indiana. He is being held at the Dearborn County Law Enforcement Center.

Although she initially vouched for the life sentence nearly a decade ago, Conley’s mother, Bridget Conley, is now asking that he be allowed to walk free someday. His attorneys also argue that his right to effective legal counsel were violated when he entered a guilty plea to murder just as his jury trial was to begin in October.

The court proceedings are expected to take several days at the Ohio County Courthouse. The court docket has the hearing scheduled to last through December 18.

Conley’s mother and psychologists are among those expected to testify.

RELATED STORIES:

Andrew Conley Seeks New Sentence For 2009 Murder Of 10-Year-Old Brother

More from Local News

Comments

Add a comment

Log in to the club or enter your details below.
Rating *

Events

Body of North Vernon man recovered from Crosley Lake

The incident remains under investigation.

Gensis: Pathways to Success Announces 2026 Summer Interns

Pictured: Owen Eldridge, Renee’ Lecher, Kate Weber, and Josie Wolfe.

Batesville Freshman's Work in BCEF’S Art on Main

The BHS mural will be on display until the fall, when a new art series will begin for the 2026-27 school year.

Local Sports Report - May 14, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Rick Bernius playing
Gary Allan - Every Storn Runs Out of Rain

Morgan Wallen Wasted on You 15:11
Rascal Flatts Banjo 15:07
Deana Carter Strawberry Wine 15:03
Fox News Fox News National Newscast 15:01