Whiskey's Lawrenceburg Origins Lead To Lawsuit

By Mike Perleberg

Made in Iowa? Or Indiana?A lawsuit alleges Templeton Rye isn't properly labeled. Photo by Carmella Schultes. (Chicago, Ill.) - A lawsuit in Chicago accuses the marketer of a purportedly small batch whiskey of not truthfully labeling that the beverage is actually distilled at MGP Ingredients’ distillery in Lawrenceburg. Templeton Rye’s bottle label states that the whiskey is “Produced and bottled by: Templeton Rye Spirits, LLC., Templeton, Iowa”. In the prohibition age, gangster Al Capone was reported to make Templeton Rye his whiskey of choice. In the class action lawsuit filed August 29 in Cook County, Illinois circuit court, plaintiff Christopher McNair claims Templeton Rye Spirits has a practice of deceptively marketing its Templeton Rye whiskey. McNair claims the company has violated Iowa and Illinois consumer fraud statutes. “Defendant has marketed Templeton Rye as being ‘small batch’ and ‘made in Iowa.’ Consumers, seeking an alternative to mainstream, mass-produced alcohols beverages have purchased hundreds of thousands of bottles of Defendant’s Templeton Rye and have paid a premium price over other whiskeys to obtain those qualities,” the complaint read. The lawsuit follows reports – The Daily Beast published this online article in July – that Templeton Rye is not a small batch. Rather, it is among the many vodka, gins, bourbon, and whiskeys mass produced by MGP Ingredients of Indiana. The plaintiffs in the class action are seeking injunctive relief, damages, and restitution. MGP Ingredients of Indiana was not named as a defendant in the lawsuit.  

More from Local News

Events

Ripley Co. Sheriff Completes National Sheriffs’ Institute Leadership Development Course

The course was held over three days in Quantico, Virginia.

Indiana Launches Enforcement Campaign to Target Distracted Driving and Speeding

Indiana’s Hands-Free Law prohibits drivers from holding mobile devices while operating a motor vehicle.

Closure Planned on State Road 250 in Switzerland County

The project will take place just east of State Road 129.

Local Sports Report - March 30, 2026

Rising Sun and Batesville picked up wins in softball.

Batesville, East Central Compete at Hoosier State Relays

The event was held at the Indiana State Fairgrounds in Indianapolis on Saturday night. 

Local Sports Report - March 27-28, 2026

Report stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Alabama - Feels So Right

Ashley McBryde Light On In The Kitchen - EAGLE ONLY NO INTRO 0:11
Russell Dickerson Worth Your Wild 0:08
Dierks Bentley Say You Do 0:05
Tracy Byrd Ten Rounds Withn Jose Quervo 0:02