State Wins $252K Judgment Against Insurance Company, Former L'burg Employee

A judge agrees with the State of Indiana that the City of Lawrenceburg's crime insurance policy provided must pay up after a former clerk-treasurer's office employee stole.

File photo

(Lawrenceburg, Ind.) - An insurance company has been ordered by a judge to pay the City of Lawrenceburg for the crimes of a former clerk-treasurer’s office employee.

Teresa Bruening was fire from the Lawrenceburg Clerk-Treasurer’s office in 2013. Then a deputy in the clerk’s office, she stole more than $40,000 by issuing herself duplicate payroll checks and extra payments over a 13-month period.

An Indiana State Board of Accounts audit completed in 2017 determined that wasn’t all Bruening cost the city. She was responsible for process payroll withholdings from other city employees which were supposed to go to the employees union pension fund. However, the payments were submitted late, resulting in $138,737 in liquidated damages and $72,742 in penalties and interest.

Bruening pleaded guilty to wire fraud in federal court in 2014.

The cost of the SBOA investigation totaled more than $22,000.

Now, a judgment has been levied against the company which provided two crime insurance policies to the City of Lawrenceburg. Indiana Attorney General Curtis Hill announced Thursday his office won a civil case against Ohio Casualty Insurance Company to recover $224,690 of the monies misappropriated by Bruening.

A news release from Hill states that in the civil case, Ohio Casualty claimed that its policies did not cover Bruening’s actions. Further, it claimed that even if its policies were applicable, too much time had elapsed since the misappropriation for it to be held liable. 

Dearborn Superior Court did not agree with Ohio Casualty and found the policies at issue to cover Bruening’s actions and entered judgment in favor of the state.

“We must always hold accountable those who illegally siphon money for themselves from the public treasury,” Attorney General Hill said. “Our office will continue seeking to recoup taxpayer dollars when public funds have been misappropriated.”

The state first sued Ohio Casualty Insurance and Bruening in Dearborn Superior Court II in 2017 seeking to recover the money under the insurance policies.

According to the July 8, 2019 order from Judge Sally A. McLaughlin, Bruening had personally repaid $27,441.27 to the city as of July 3, 2017, which was offset from the overall judgment of $252,131.35.

RELATED STORIES:

State Audit: Former City Employee Owes Lawrenceburg $274K

More from Local News

Comments

Add a comment

Log in to the club or enter your details below.
Rating *

Events

Madison Man Arrested for Possession of Child Sexual Abuse Material

Brian Shockey was placed under arrest on 11/16/2026.

Local Painting Auction Turns into Support for People and Their Pets

Billie Pierce’s original painting, “Life of Many Colors” generated $3,450 for the Patriot Passion Project Food Bank.

High School Hoops Scores - November 13-14, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Two Local High School Football Teams Advance to Semi-State

The East Central Trojans will play on Friday and the Milan Indians will play on Saturday.

South Dearborn Cheer is National Bound

The squad will compete at ESPN Wide World of Sports in January.

Billy Currington Must Be Doing Something Right 0:50
Eli Young Band Even If It Breaks Your Heart 0:46
Restless Heart Back to the Heartbreak Kid 0:42
Brett Young You Didn't 0:38