Death Row Inmate Seeking New Trial in 30-Year-Old Murder Case

Jeffrey Wogenstahl was convicted in 1993 for the murder of Amber Garrett.

Amber Garrett

CINCINNATI – Death row inmate Jeffrey Wogenstahl is seeking a new trial after more than three decades since his conviction for killing a 10-year-old girl from Harrison.

Amber Garrett was kidnapped from her Harrison home in 1991 and was later found dead in Bright, Indiana.

Wogenstahl, 63, was found guilty of kidnapping and murder in 1993.

Hearings are taking place this week in Hamilton County, where Wogenstahl’s legal team are arguing that specific evidence was supressed during the original trial.

Hearings are expected to continue for multiple days.

More from Local News

Events

Southeast Indiana Food Drive Collects 374 Food Items for the Community

A month-long food drive took place in four southeastern Indiana counties.

MIFC Announces All-Conference Team, Players of the Year

The MIFC returned after a four-year absence.

Eli Aston Once Again Enters Record Book at The Mount

Aston had a big game on Saturday to add to his impressive sophomore totals.

Local Sports Report - November 7-8, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Neal McCoy The Shake 16:53
Craig Morgan Redneck Yacht Club 16:45
Andy Griggs You Won't Ever Be Lonely 16:41
Jelly Roll and Brandon Lake Hard Fought Hallelujah 16:38