Batesville Casket Settles Lawsuit For $19M

By Mike Perleberg (Batesville, Ind.) – A local casket manufacturing company is agreeing to pay nearly $19 million to a competitor. Batesville Casket Company was sued by Matthews International Corporation, based in Pittsburgh, in U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. Matthews alleged that Batesville unlawfully poached customers of two Matthews' subsidiary companies, breached employment contracts of two high-level Matthews employees, and improperly interfered with the companies’ business relations. On Monday, Matthews announced that Batesville settled the lawsuit by agreeing to pay the company $17 million. The southeast Indiana company will also pay $1.75 million to cover attorney fees for two former Matthews employees. The lawsuit also named as defendants Harry Pontone and Scott Pontone for allegedly breaching their employment covenants. Batesville Casket will pay their settlement costs. "Following the actions involved in this case, I am pleased the defendants have agreed to settle the case for a significant amount. On behalf of myself, Matthews, and all the Pontone family members engaged with Matthews, I would like to thank our customers for their continued loyalty and our longstanding employees for the tremendous contributions they make every day delivering outstanding service to our customers," said Thomas Pontone, President of Matthews Funeral Home Products Division.  

More from Local News

Events

Arrest Made After Wanted Person Check at Home on Salt Fork Road

The Dearborn County Sheriff's Office issued a press release on Wednesday.

One Day Closure Announced for Union Ridge Road

This closure is part of the ongoing North Hogan Road Bridge project.

SD's Ballart Ready to Sign with U of L

Ballart received his official offer this month after being verbally committed since last September.

East Central Girls Basketball Enjoys Stellar Summer

The Lady Trojans won a bunch of games and had five players invited to a prestigious event.

Local Sports Report - August 4, 2025

Report missing high school stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Jake Owen - Made For You

Toby Keith How Do You Like Me Now? 2:40
Joe Nichols Sunny and 75 2:36
Mitchell Tenpenny Truth About You 2:33
Clint Black Nothin But The Taillights 2:28