Pence Pleads Guilty in Sibling Shooting Death

The incident occurred in December 2024

Crystal Pence

(Brookville, Ind.) - Crystal Pence has pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter for shooting and killing her brother, Ronald Pence. 

The shooting took place in December of 2024 at an apartment complex on Fairfield Avenue. When Indiana State Police arrived at the scene, Ronald Pence had sustained a gunshot wound to the chest. Immediate medical aid was provided, but the life-saving measures were unsuccessful

Crystal, who was 29 at the time of the shooting, was taken into custody at the scene. 

She was originally charged with murder but pleaded to a lesser felony charge during a pre-trial hearing on Wednesday. 

Pence is facing 10 to 30 years behind bars and a lifetime on probation. 

Sentencing is scheduled for September 23

RELATED STORIES

Murder Trial Pushed Back in Brookville

ISP Detectives Investigating Early Morning Shooting in Brookville 

More from Local News

Events

The Milan Miracle: More than A Movie

Before Mendoza There Was Milan.

Culvert Replacement Project at U.S. 50 and S.R. 129 Intersection

Flagging operations are expected to take up to four days.

Two Local High School Football Teams Advance to Semi-State

The East Central Trojans will play on Friday and the Milan Indians will play on Saturday.

South Dearborn Cheer is National Bound

The squad will compete at ESPN Wide World of Sports in January.

Conner 8th Grade Team to Play for State Championship

They will travel to Lexington on Saturday for the big game!

High School Hoops Scores - November 11-12, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Chelsie playing
Montgomery Gentry - Lucky Man

Alabama I'm In A Hurry 7:20
George Strait Cowboys and Dreamers 7:16
Luke Bryan Crash My Party 7:09
Gary Allan Her Man 7:06