Florence Hotel Murder Suspect Pleads Not Guilty

The murder suspect's aunt says he had mental health issues.

Amanda Webster was murdered in a Florence hotel room on Saturday, December 1. Photo via GoFundMe.

(Boone County, Ky.) - There's no word yet on a motive for the murder of an Arizona mother in a Boone County hotel room.

Jesse A. James pleaded not guilty to murder and tampering with evidence charges during his initial appearance in court Monday. He remains held in the Boone County Jail on a $1 million bond.

Florence Police say James, 32, of Burlington, killed Amanda Webster, 26, Saturday morning at the Home 2 Suites in Florence. Webster’s body was found in a hotel room which had been rented in James’ name.

James was arrested at the Rave Cinema in Florence later Saturday. Upon being questioned, he allegedly admitted to the murder.

James' relatives told local media that his untreated mental health issues could be behind his motivation to kill. Mildred Scherder, James’ aunt, told WCPO-TV that her nephew suffers from paranoid schizophrenia and was off of his medication.

Webster was a mother of three from Cameron, Arizona – her children ages 10 years, two years, and three months. A GoFundMe page to raise money for her funeral expenses says she was a traveling mother who worked state to state.

Jesse A. James. Photo by Boone County Sheriff's Office.

RELATED STORIES:

Murder Discovered In Florence Hotel Room; Suspect Arrested

More from Local News


Events

UPDATE: All Westbound Lanes Reopen on Carroll Cropper Bridge

An eastbound single lane closure is continuing.

Survey Shows Majority of Hoosiers Favor Balanced Forest Management of Woodlands

The survey was conducted by Purdue's Department of Forestry and Natural Resources and D. J. Case & Associates.

SDCSC to Host Community Input Sessions Regarding Profile of a Graduate Plan

Profile of a Graduate is part of new strategic plan goals approved by the school board.

Franklin Co. Boys Basketball Enjoys Unique Practice Experience

It is not every day you get to practice at an NBA arena.

Local Sports Report - December 23, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountyonline.com

Record Breakers Highlight ORVC Report for December 15-20

Three ORVC swimmers have set new school records.

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
George Strait - X - Old Time Christmas

Ronnie Milsap X - Silver Bells 4:44
Brett Eldredge X - God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen 4:41
Maddie & Tae X - We Need Christmas 4:37
Luke Bryan X - Run, Run Rudolph 4:34