David Ison Won't Face Death Penalty

David Ison

Ripley County Sheriff's Office

(Brookville, Ind.) – David Ison, the man accused of murdering five people in Franklin County, will not face the death penalty, county prosecutor Mel Wilhelm said Friday.

 

Wilhelm filed a life-in-prison-without-parole charge in Franklin Circuit Court, a sixth charge in addition to the five murder charges Ison, 46, already faces.

 

Ison, a Fayette County resident, allegedly shot Roy Napier, his estranged wife Angela, their two grown children and family friend Henry Smith at two homes on Stipps Hill Road near Laurel on September 25. Ison’s then girlfriend told police that Ison shot the family because Roy Napier had raised the price of prescription pills Ison was trying to buy from Napier.

 

Police were called to the murder scene after neighbors drove upon Melissa Napier’s four-year-old daughter wandering in the road. She was the only survivor of the massacre.

 

According to the Richmond Palladium-Item, Wilhelm had considered filing death penalty charges against Ison and presented the case in October to the Capital Litigation Committee of the Indiana Prosecuting Attorneys Council for its evaluation.

 

Citing the publicity the murder case has received, Ison’s defense attorney filed for a change of venue for the trial. Franklin Circuit Court Judge Steven Cox granted that request in November. 

 

Cox could rule soon on where the trial would be located.

 

A death penalty trial could have been costly for Franklin County. County officials have been discussing a possible short government shutdown to save funds to prosecute Ison for the death penalty.

 

LINKS:

 

Murder Suspect Granted Change of Venue

 

Murder Suspect Wants Trial Moved

 

Ison Pleads Not Guilty To Franklin Co. Murders

 

Ison Charged With Five Murders

 

Laurel Five Laid To Rest

 

Services Set For Metamora Massacre Victims

 

Ison Held On $5M Bond

 

Person of Interest Held In Murder Case

 

Killer Not Among Five Dead

 

ISP: No Persons Of Interest In Five Deaths

 

Questions Abound In Franklin Co. Deaths

 

Five Found Dead In Two Metamora Homes

 

Multiple Homicides Investigated In Franklin Co.

More from Local News

Events

The Community Project Receives $1,000 Grant from DCF

The Community Project focuses on the core needs of struggling Dearborn County residents.

BCEF's Student Success Center Opens at Batesville High School

The comprehensive academic and emotional wellness hub designed to support students’ needs, is now open.

Ohio Co. Tourism Reschedules Merry Little Christmas Celebration

Due to the weather forecast, the event is being moved back a week.

Local Sports Report - December 12, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Former EC Star Named College All-American

This is not the only postseason award for the Mount St. Joseph star.

Local Sports Report - December 10, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Little Texas - What Might Have Been

Brad Paisley Alcohol 22:52
Jordan Foster They All Do 22:49
Brett Eldredge X - White Christmas 22:46
Tyler Hubbard 5 Foot 9 22:43