20 Year Sentence Handed To Ball Bat Attacker

Jeremiah McIntosh

Ripley County Sheriff's Office

(Versailles, Ind.) - Jeffrey Benham lost his life when he was cracked in the head with a baseball bat in April of 2011.

 

Now, the man who swung that bat, Jeremiah McIntosh, will lose 20 years of freedom.

 

Ripley Circuit Court Judge Carl Taul handed down the sentence to the 34-year-old on Monday during a crowded and emotional sentencing hearing, the Osgood Journal reports. In December, McIntosh had pleaded guilty to a charge of Voluntary Manslaughter.

 

Three of the 20 years were suspended to probation. McIntosh was given credit for 271 days already served in jail before sentencing.

 

McIntosh had fled to Florida after an April 3 fight at his Versailles area home with Jeffrey Benham. He was arrested on a Ripley County warrant in Florida.

 

Witnesses said a mob of about 40 people including Benham had come to McIntosh’s home on Benham Road just a day after McIntosh was released from jail on a separate charge.

 

McIntosh’s brother claimed Jeremiah was only defending himself when he struck Benham, 48, in the head with the bat. Ripley County deputies arrived on the scene and found Benham on the ground bleeding.

 

Benham died in the hospital two weeks later.

 

“This is such a bad thing. I loved my son like your mother loves you,” Benham’s mother, Charlene told McIntosh during Monday's hearing. “I’m trying to forgive you. I will forgive you.”

 

LINKS:

 

Holton Man Pleas To Baseball Bat Attack

 

Man In Baseball Bat Attack Charged With Manslaughter

More from Local News

Events

Oldenburg Academy and Freudenfest Committee Launch Maypole Heritage Park Initiative

The project is expected to be completed in Spring 2026.

School Report Leads to Arrest of Sexually Violent Predator

School Resource Officer Alex Campbell was made aware that male subject, Brandon Strickland, who is listed as a Sexually Violent Predator, had entered on to a school property.

Indiana State Police Investigating Officer Involved Shooting in Decatur County

This investigation is ongoing and there is no further information at this time.

Local Sports Report - August 26, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Greendale Middle School Boys Cross Country Team Earns 2nd Place at Greensburg Invitational

One of the largest middle school cross country events in the state.

On Air

Eagle Country 99.3 playing
Brett Young - Drink With You

Little Texas Some Guys Have All the Love 13:17
Tyler Farr Guy Walks Into A Bar 13:14
Gabby Barrett I Hope 13:08
Tracy Lawrence How A Cowgirl Says Goodbye 13:04