AG Curtis Hill Asks Supreme Court To Uphold Indiana Law Regarding Parental Notice For Minor's Abortions

Monday, December 30th, 2019 10:42am

By Indiana Attorney General Curtis Hill, press release

SCOTUS is 'the only institution that can give an authoritative answer,' federal appeals judge says.

Attorney General Curtis Hill on Friday asked the U.S. Supreme Court to affirm the constitutionality of Indiana’s law requiring parental notice when minors obtain abortions.

The law at issue applies to minors who already have obtained an exemption from a juvenile court allowing them to proceed with an abortion without parental permission as typically required under Indiana law. The law requires parental notice except for when a juvenile court rules that notifying parents is not in the minor’s best interests, such as when the child lives with abusive family members.

A three-judge panel of the Seventh Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals has previously upheld a preliminary injunction against the enforcement of Indiana’s parental notice law. That court then declined Indiana's petition for a rehearing of the matter by the full court.

A rehearing would be pointless because only the U.S. Supreme Court at this stage can adequately clarify how its own precedents apply to abortion regulations such as Indiana’s law, one Seventh Circuit judge stated.

“It is better to send this dispute on its way to the only institution that can give an authoritative answer,” wrote Judge Frank Easterbrook.

The appellate court’s difficulty making sense of the tangled web of case law is telling, Attorney General Hill said.

“When even the most experienced and distinguished members of the federal judiciary throw up their hands in confused frustration,” Attorney General Hill said, “it is time for our nation’s highest court to issue guidance.”

A look back to America’s founding documents should bode well for Indiana’s law, he added.

“Nothing in the U.S. Constitution prohibits Indiana from requiring parental notification when an unemancipated minor is getting an abortion,” Attorney General Hill said. “Even to get a tattoo, a minor in Indiana needs parental permission. Quite simply, parents have rights and responsibilities in the care and upbringing of a child.”

Further, on a practical level, Indiana’s law helps protect the child’s own well-being, Attorney General Hill added.

“An abortion is a medical procedure that could have implications for a child’s future treatment,” he said. “It’s an event that could bear on a child’s emotional needs and mental health, and it’s an event that parents need to know about in order to provide nurturing care and guidance.”

Attached is Indiana’s petition to the Supreme Court.

More from Local News


Events

  • St. Vincent de Paul

    Food Pantry open every Thursday from 10am until 2 pm. 210 Fifth St., Aurora, IN. 47001 812 926-1637

    at Pantry
  • Homeschool Tech Series: Conquer Your Computer

    Homeschool Teens! Conquer your computer with Google Docs, Sheets and Slides in this three-week program for homeschool students in grades 6-12. Registration is required and attendance at all three classes is suggested. 1 p.m. to 3 p.m. Friday, Jan. 14, 21 & 28, Lawrenceburg Main Library. Register at www.lpld.lib.in.us/calendar. 812-537-2775. Teens. Free. You may need to register by phone while the library district switches to a new online reservation system.

    at Lawrenceburg Public Library District
  • Celebrate the Legacy of Betty White

    Watch a movie featuring Betty White while we make crafts and eat a snack in honor of her 100th birthday. (Hint: think cheesecake, roses, etc.) noon to 3 p.m. Saturday, Jan. 29. Must register at: www.lpld.lib.in.us/calendar. Adults. Free. You may need to register by phone while the library district switches to a new online reservation system.

    at Lawrenceburg Public Library District

Unemployment Rates Drop in SEI Counties

The statewide average is at a record low.

Lawrenceburg Natives to Represent Team USA at 2022 Winter Olympics

Good luck to Nick Goepper and Justin Schoenefeld.

Town of Sunman Asking Residents to Complete Comprehensive Plan Survey

Sunman is in the process of trying to obtain a grant to fund the development of a comprehensive plan.

Local Sports Report - February 26, 2022

The Franklin County Wildcats boys basketball team extended their win streak to 12 games.

Local Sports Report - January 25, 2022

South Ripley's girls basketball team took charge of the ORVC, but Switzerland County and JCD still have title hopes.

Area Senior Guards Make HBCA All-District Team

The All-District Teams recognized the best senior players in southern Indiana.

On Air

Robb Reel playing
Collin Raye - That's My Story

Brett Young You Didn't 9:42
Lee Brice Rumor 9:39
Lee Ann Womack Little Past Little Rock 9:32
Billy Currington Don't 9:28